An offer is not a percentage pulled from the air. It begins with realistic resale — not an optimistic asking price — then accounts for fees, testing, time, inventory risk, and the margin required to stay in business.
The framework
A common reference is about 65% of realistic resale, with roughly 60–70% as a fair range. That is a framework, not a universal quote: condition, liquidity, authenticity risk, and selling costs can change the result.
Show the work
- Identify what is melt-driven and what is premium-driven.
- Use comparable sold results, not active listings.
- Subtract marketplace and transaction costs.
- Account for time, grading risk, returns, and slow inventory.
- Put the number and the assumptions in writing.
Two people should see the same math
A transparent method protects the seller from a mystery offer and the buyer from paying for optimism.
Related
- Set the maximum buy before you bid
- Junk-Silver Flip Math: Buy Price vs. Melt vs. eBay Net
- The Weekend Coin Dealer
FREE DOWNLOAD
Before you spend that coin, check it.
The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.
