Skip to main content
The field manual

Coin Collecting Guides

Field-tested checklists for grading, silver math, key dates, and buying & selling — built for the coin show, the estate table, and your desk.


Start here

8 guides

01

The first 48 hours with an inherited collection

What to do (and not do) in the first two days: safe handling, a quick inventory, and the mistakes that cost heirs real money.

Read the guide →

02

The Thanksgiving table where this started

The family story behind Caps Coins & Treasures — and why this field manual exists.

Read the guide →

03

Sort a coin box into three useful piles

A fast triage system: what to research, what to spend, and what to set aside for a second look.

Read the guide →

04

What “collectible” actually means

Collector demand — not age or shine — decides value. The three questions that define “collectible.”

Read the guide →

05

Why “shiny” is not a grade

Polish, plating, and cleaning can fake mint luster. Learn what real original surfaces look like.

Read the guide →

06

Coin Collecting Supplies Starter Kit

The short list of tools worth buying first — loupe, scale, flips — and what you can safely skip.

Read the guide →

07

How to Store Coins So They Don’t Lose Value

Flips, tubes, and albums that protect value — plus the storage mistakes that quietly destroy it.

Read the guide →

08

What to Do with an Inherited Coin Collection

A calm, step-by-step path from “a box of coins” to informed decisions about keeping or selling.

Read the guide →

Silver math & melt

10 guides

01

The 0.715 rule for 90% U.S. silver

Multiply face value by 0.715 to estimate pure silver. The fastest math in junk-silver buying.

Read the guide →

02

Convert grams to troy ounces correctly

31.1035 grams per troy ounce — not 28.35. Get the conversion right before you price any metal.

Read the guide →

03

Understand the “junk silver” category

Worn 90% U.S. coins trade near melt. What counts as junk silver — and what doesn’t.

Read the guide →

04

Junk-Silver Halves: Franklin, Walking Liberty, and Kennedy 40% Silver

Silver content by half-dollar type, from 90% Franklins and Walkers to 40% Kennedy halves.

Read the guide →

05

Junk-Silver Flip Math: Buy Price vs. Melt vs. eBay Net

Work a flip three ways — what you pay, what it melts for, and what you keep after fees.

Read the guide →

06

Check spot before every buying trip

Silver moves daily. Build the 30-second spot-check habit that protects every purchase.

Read the guide →

07

Melt is a floor, not the whole price

Melt sets the minimum. Premiums, rarity, and condition decide what a coin is really worth.

Read the guide →

08

Carry two numbers: melt and premium

Walk into every deal knowing the melt value and the premium — and never confuse the two.

Read the guide →

09

Junk Silver Bags: What a $1,000 Bag Is Really Worth

A $1,000 face-value bag of 90% U.S. silver coinage (1964 and earlier): actual silver content and real-world value.

Read the guide →

10

What Does Troy Ounce Mean?

The 31.1035-gram unit behind every precious-metal price — and why it isn’t an ordinary ounce.

Read the guide →

Grading & value

22 guides

01

Read the Sheldon scale in useful neighborhoods

Forget memorizing 70 grades. Learn the bands — Good, Fine, XF, AU, Mint State — that actually drive price.

Read the guide →

02

Use cartwheel luster to separate wear from shine

Tilt the coin: rotating cartwheel luster means original mint surfaces; dead shine means wear or cleaning.

Read the guide →

03

Morgan wear points: ear, cheek, breast, bow, rim

The five high points where friction shows first on a Morgan dollar — check them in order.

Read the guide →

04

Read a Morgan dollar from photographs

Grade a Morgan from seller photos alone: which angles reveal wear, and which hide it.

Read the guide →

05

Morgan Dollars: The Most Misgraded-from-Photos Series (Long-Form)

The deep dive on why Morgans fool cameras — strike softness, bag marks, and deceptive luster.

Read the guide →

06

Mercury Dime Wear Points (Grading From Photos)

Bands, fasces, and cheek: the exact wear points that separate a Full Bands dime from an also-ran.

Read the guide →

07

Tell random bag marks from systematic wear

Bag marks are random; wear is systematic. Learn the difference before you assign a grade.

Read the guide →

08

Five ways seller lighting can hide evidence

Overexposure, angle tricks, and color shifts — how listing photos mislead, and how to see through them.

Read the guide →

09

Scan every rim and edge

Rims tell the truth about handling. A two-minute rim-and-edge scan that catches what photos miss.

Read the guide →

10

Separate stable toning from environmental damage

Rainbow toning can add value; corrosion never does. How to tell stable patina from active damage.

Read the guide →

11

Recognize a mechanically whizzed surface

Whizzing fakes mint luster with a wire brush. The tell-tale flow lines that expose it.

Read the guide →

12

Compare original surfaces with cleaned surfaces

Side by side: what original skin looks like versus the dull, hairlined look of a cleaning.

Read the guide →

13

Read surfaces in a fixed loupe sequence

A repeatable loupe routine — fields, devices, rims — so you never miss a problem area.

Read the guide →

14

The Loupe Surface Exam, Live

A full surface exam in real time: the order, the angles, and what each reveal means.

Read the guide →

15

Build grading skill with a 50-photo drill

Fifty photos, fifty grades. The deliberate-practice drill that calibrates your eye fast.

Read the guide →

16

Run the slab-or-not calculation

Certification costs money. The math that decides whether a coin is worth sending to PCGS or NGC.

Read the guide →

17

Connect grade risk to buying margin

Uncertain grade? Widen your margin. How grading risk should shape every offer you make.

Read the guide →

18

Coin Grading Basics

The starter’s map of coin grading: scales, standards, and why two points can mean hundreds of dollars.

Read the guide →

19

PCGS vs. NGC

The two top grading services compared — holders, standards, specialties, and which to choose when.

Read the guide →

20

Mint Set vs. Proof Set

Mint sets hold business strikes; proof sets are made for collectors. What each contains and what drives value.

Read the guide →

21

What Is a Proof Coin?

Mirror fields, frosted devices, special dies: how proof coins are made and why they command premiums.

Read the guide →

22

What Is Coin Toning?

The chemistry of toned silver and copper — when color adds eye appeal and when it signals damage.

Read the guide →

Key dates

6 guides

01

What Is a Key Date? (The Concept Explainer)

Low mintage plus high demand: the concept that explains why one date in a series costs 100× the rest.

Read the guide →

02

What makes a coin a key date?

Mintage, survival rate, and collector pressure — the three forces that crown a key date.

Read the guide →

03

1916-D Mercury dime: the certified-only rule

The most faked key date in U.S. coinage. Why you should never buy one raw.

Read the guide →

04

1914-D Lincoln cent: a key-date checkpoint

What to verify before paying key-date money for the 1914-D — mint mark, color, and surfaces.

Read the guide →

05

1932-D Washington quarter: first-year scarcity

Low mintage, first-year hype: why the 1932-D anchors the Washington series.

Read the guide →

06

What Is a Key Date Coin?

Key dates, semi-keys, and better dates defined — with examples across popular U.S. series.

Read the guide →

Gold basics

5 guides

01

Gold Basics for the Coin Buyer

Purity, weight, and premium: the fundamentals every first-time gold buyer should know.

Read the guide →

02

Bullion Basics: How to Buy Gold & Silver Without Getting Ripped Off

Dealers, premiums, and red flags — a safe-buying playbook for bullion beginners.

Read the guide →

03

How to Buy Gold Coins Without Getting Burned

Avoid overpaying: compare premiums, verify authenticity, and choose reputable sellers.

Read the guide →

04

Gold Buffalo vs. Gold Eagle: Which Should You Buy?

American Gold Eagle (1986 – present) versus Gold Buffalo (2006 – present): purity, premiums, and liquidity compared.

Read the guide →

05

Gold Sovereign vs. Krugerrand

Britain’s historic sovereign against South Africa’s Krugerrand — premiums, recognition, and resale.

Read the guide →

Counterfeit screening & authentication

13 guides

01

Build a practical counterfeit-screening kit

Scale, calipers, magnet, loupe: the compact kit that catches most fakes before money changes hands.

Read the guide →

02

Use weight as the first objective screen

A tenth of a gram off is a red flag. Why weight is the fastest, most objective fake test.

Read the guide →

03

Measure diameter twice

Calipers don’t lie: how a quick diameter check exposes cast and struck counterfeits.

Read the guide →

04

Know what the magnet test can—and cannot—prove

A magnet catches iron fakes but misses the rest. The limits every buyer must understand.

Read the guide →

05

Use the ring test only as a screen

The ping test hints at composition — but it’s a screen, not a verdict. How to use it well.

Read the guide →

06

Inspect a suspicious added mint mark

Added mint marks turn cheap coins into “rarities.” Tool marks and texture tell the real story.

Read the guide →

07

Look for altered digits and date spacing

Too-good dates get faked by altering digits. Spacing, style, and alignment give them away.

Read the guide →

08

Look for the ghost of a removed mint mark

Removed mint marks leave a ghost: disturbed metal and faint outlines under magnification.

Read the guide →

09

Use one pre-purchase sequence every time

The same five checks, in the same order, every purchase — consistency beats inspiration.

Read the guide →

10

Turn authentication into a practiced routine

From occasional checks to second nature: drilling authentication until it’s automatic.

Read the guide →

11

Machine Doubling vs. Real Doubled Die: The Tell That Saves You Money

Flat, shelf-like machine doubling versus true hub doubling — the distinction worth real money.

Read the guide →

12

1955 doubled die: real doubling versus flat doubling

The famous 1955 doubled-die cent: how to confirm genuine hub doubling and reject flat strike doubling.

Read the guide →

13

How to Spot a Fake Gold Coin

Weight, dimensions, ping, and visual tells — a practical screen for fake gold before you buy.

Read the guide →

Buying playbooks

10 guides

01

Approach estate sales with a written buy list

Walk in with targets and max prices. The written list that keeps estate-sale emotion in check.

Read the guide →

02

Use coin shows as a pricing classroom

A bourse floor is live market data. How to read cases, ask prices, and calibrate your eye.

Read the guide →

03

Set the maximum buy before you bid

Decide your ceiling before the adrenaline starts. The pre-commitment rule for auctions.

Read the guide →

04

Let a too-good price slow the deal down

Steal-priced coins deserve extra scrutiny, not faster hands. When a bargain is a warning.

Read the guide →

05

Evaluate the seller as part of the coin

Reputation, knowledge, and return policy are part of what you’re buying. Vet the source.

Read the guide →

06

Price from sold listings, not wishes

Asking prices are fiction; sold listings are data. How to research real market value.

Read the guide →

07

Explain an offer from realistic resale

Anchor your offer in what you can actually resell for — and say so plainly.

Read the guide →

08

Turn coin evidence into a written offer record

Document grade, comps, and costs behind each offer. Paper trails protect both sides.

Read the guide →

09

Coin Shows: A Beginner’s Guide

First bourse? What to bring, how dealers work, and the etiquette that gets you better prices.

Read the guide →

10

Penny Roll Hunting

Search bank rolls for wheat cents, silver, and errors — the low-cost hunt anyone can start.

Read the guide →

Selling playbooks

11 guides

01

Choose the right selling route for an inherited collection

Dealer, auction, or direct? Match the collection’s value and your timeline to the right channel.

Read the guide →

02

Choose auction or Buy It Now on purpose

Each eBay format serves different coins. Pick deliberately instead of defaulting.

Read the guide →

03

Know when one eBay listing is not worth it

Fees and time can erase thin margins. The break-even test to run before you list.

Read the guide →

04

eBay Fee Math: Why a $140 Sale Nets $15

A real fee teardown: final value fees, shipping, and promoted listings versus what you keep.

Read the guide →

05

Calculate true net before listing a coin

Work backward from sold prices through every fee to your true net — before you commit.

Read the guide →

06

Photograph the coin, including its problems

Honest photos sell faster and cut returns. Light, angle, and full disclosure.

Read the guide →

07

Ship like the sale still depends on it

Because it does: packaging, tracking, and insurance that protect five-star feedback.

Read the guide →

08

Budget for returns, promotion, and lost time

The hidden costs of selling online — build them into pricing or watch margin vanish.

Read the guide →

09

Keep a sale record the family can follow

A simple ledger of what sold, for what, and where the money went.

Read the guide →

10

How to Sell Your Coins for the Most Money

The complete selling playbook: timing, venue, presentation, and negotiation.

Read the guide →

11

How to Photograph Coins for eBay

Copy-stand basics, lighting, and macro technique for photos that earn bids.

Read the guide →

Dealer discipline

5 guides

01

The Weekend Coin Dealer operating rhythm

Buy days, list days, ship days: the weekly cadence that keeps a part-time coin business profitable.

Read the guide →

02

From collector habits to dealer discipline

Collectors fall in love; dealers run numbers. The mindset shift that protects your capital.

Read the guide →

03

The two-wallet rule in one page

Collection money and business money never mix. The one-page rule, explained.

Read the guide →

04

Keep the collection wallet separate

Why your personal collection needs its own accounting — and how to enforce the boundary.

Read the guide →

05

Decide whether grading adds enough value

Slabbing costs real money. The calculation that says when certification pays and when it doesn’t.

Read the guide →

World coin trails

5 guides

01

Japan coin hunt: a pre-trip field plan

Research, targets, and logistics for hunting coins in Japan — before you board the plane.

Read the guide →

02

Build a Japan coin-hunt hit list

Which Japanese issues to chase, what they sell for, and how to prioritize the hunt.

Read the guide →

03

Compare Tokyo shop tags with sold listings

Tokyo asking prices versus realized eBay prices — where the arbitrage actually lives.

Read the guide →

04

Plan the Nakano Broadway field report

How to work Nakano Broadway’s coin shops methodically and report back with real data.

Read the guide →

05

A core path through Puerto Rico coinage

From Spanish colonial issues to modern commemoratives: the essential Puerto Rico tour. Also see: What Is Puerto Rico’s Currency?

Read the guide →

Mercury dime set series

4 guides

01

Building the 77-coin Mercury dime set

The complete roadmap: all 77 dates and mint marks, key stops, and realistic budgeting.

Read the guide →

02

The recorded eight-coin Mercury chase list

Eight target coins, documented start to finish — the hunt as a teaching series.

Read the guide →

03

Why the Mercury set hunt is a teaching series

What chasing one full set teaches about grading, patience, and market discipline.

Read the guide →

04

Slot-Fill Episode Format (Mercury Set Series)

The episode template behind the series: research, hunt, grade, and slot each coin.

Read the guide →

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.