Skip to main content

Bullion Basics: How to Buy Gold & Silver Without Getting Ripped Off




Bullion means precious metal valued by weight and purity — gold and silver coins and bars bought as metal, not as collectibles. The entire game is two numbers: the live spot price and the premium you pay over it. This guide covers what bullion is, how pricing works, where to buy, the red flags that mark a rip-off, and how to sell when the time comes.

What “bullion” actually means

  • Bullion = metal valued by weight. A 1 oz American Gold Eagle is worth (1 oz × gold spot) + a small premium. A rare 1933 double eagle is worth millions because of numismatic rarity — that is collecting, not bullion. Most beginners should start with bullion (goldsilver.ai; Provident Metals).
  • Troy ounces, not regular ounces. Precious metals trade in troy ounces: 1 troy oz = 31.1035 grams. A “1 oz” gold coin holds one troy ounce of pure gold — an American Gold Eagle weighs more than 1 oz gross because it’s alloyed to 22K for durability but still contains exactly 1 troy oz of pure gold (goldsilver.ai).
  • Spot price is the live market price per troy ounce of pure metal, set by global futures markets. It moves constantly during trading hours — any “melt value” you compute is only valid at that moment’s spot (FXEmpire).
  • Premium = everything above melt. Minting, distribution, dealer margin. Fair premiums: small single-digit percentages for common 1 oz bullion coins; higher for fractional coins (minting cost spread over less metal), proofs, and anything with collector demand (Provident Metals).

How pricing works: the only math you need

  • Melt value = pure metal content (troy oz) × spot price. Pure content = gross weight × fineness. Example: a 90% silver half dollar weighs 12.5 g → 12.5 × 0.90 = 11.25 g pure = 0.3617 troy oz → × $30/oz silver spot = $10.85 melt (Pacific Precious Metals; findbullionprices.com).
  • What you pay = melt + premium. What a dealer pays you = melt − their margin (refining cost + profit). Expect to sell below spot and buy above it — the spread is how dealers stay in business (FXEmpire).
  • Junk silver math: pre-1965 U.S. dimes, quarters and halves are 90% silver (“junk silver” / “constitutional silver”), typically traded in $1,000 face-value bags. One widely used rule of thumb: a $1,000 bag contains about 715 troy oz of pure silver after accounting for wear — always verify the factor your dealer uses (findbullionprices.com).
  • Numismatic News’s rule of thumb for selling gold: if a buyer offers less than 75% of actual melt value for scrap gold, find another buyer (Numismatic News).

Where to buy

  • Major online bullion dealers (the big national names) — transparent premiums, insured shipping, buy-back policies. Compare premiums across two or three before ordering.
  • Local coin shops — you can inspect before buying and usually pay cash with no shipping; premiums run slightly higher than the big online dealers.
  • eBay — fine for common bullion from high-feedback sellers; check sold listings (not asking prices) to calibrate. Use the market-check links throughout this wiki.
  • Government mints — the U.S. Mint sells proof and burnished collector versions (at higher premiums); bullion Eagles/Buffalos go through authorized dealers, not direct.
  • What to avoid: unsolicited callers pushing “rare” or “collectible” coins at huge premiums, anyone who won’t quote you the premium over spot, and deals priced below melt (counterfeit signal).

Red flags: how beginners get ripped off

  • Grade-inflation and “semi-numismatic” markup. Common bullion coins in fancy packaging sold at 30–50% premiums with stories about future rarity. Bullion is bullion — pay a bullion premium.
  • Bait-and-switch on gold content. Know the fineness before you buy: American Gold Eagle .9167 (22K), Gold Buffalo .9999 (24K), Krugerrand .9167, Maple Leaf .9999. Only the gold fraction carries melt value (goldsilver.ai).
  • Counterfeits. Tungsten-core fake gold bars and coins match weight but fail on dimensions, ping, or XRF. A 0.01 g scale plus calipers plus the genuine specs (listed on every coin entry in this wiki) catch most fakes. For large purchases, buy certified (PCGS/NGC) or from dealers who test in front of you.
  • Leverage and “storage programs.” Anyone selling you gold you can’t hold or audit is selling you a promise, not metal.
  • Pressure tactics. “Gold is about to explode, buy now” is a sales script, not analysis.

Storing and selling

  • Storage: home safes are fine for modest holdings (bolted down, discreet, insured via a rider); safe-deposit boxes and private vaults for larger ones. Never store bullion where its existence is widely known. Full guide: How to Store Coins So They Don’t Lose Value.
  • Selling: get quotes from at least two dealers plus check eBay sold listings; expect 2–8% under spot for common bullion depending on form and quantity. Keep purchase receipts — your cost basis matters at tax time (consult a tax professional).

Bullion guides on this wiki

Market check

Compare live bullion listings on eBay:

Search eBay for gold bullion coins

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.