The Buffalo nickel (1913–1938) is America’s most sculptural five-cent piece — and its famous varieties, from the 1918/7-D overdate to the three-legged 1937-D, can each cost more than a complete set of regular issues.
Series history
- Designed by sculptor James Earle Fraser, the Buffalo nickel shows a composite Native American portrait — modeled from three life models — and Black Diamond, a bison from the New York Zoo, on the reverse (Stack’s Bowers).
- Struck 1913–1938, the series came in two types: the 1913 Type 1 with the bison on a raised mound, quickly changed to Type 2 with the denomination recessed, because the raised mound wore down too fast (Stack’s Bowers).
- The date sits on a raised point of the design and wears away quickly — most Buffalo nickels found in circulation by the 1960s were dateless (Stack’s Bowers).
- Total business-strike production was about 1.17 billion pieces across Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco (Stack’s Bowers).
- No nickels were struck in 1922; after the 25-year design term expired, the Jefferson nickel replaced the Buffalo in 1938 (Liberty Coin Service checklist; NM Estate Auctions).
Key dates
- 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel — the scarcest of the six 1913 issues and a first-year key.
- 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel — the series’ only overdate; scarce in all grades, with Uncirculated examples major rarities (Stack’s Bowers).
- 1921-S Buffalo Nickel — a low-mintage San Francisco key of the early 1920s (Dr. Sol Taylor).
- 1924-S Buffalo Nickel and 1926-S Buffalo Nickel — the toughest late-1920s branch-mint dates; PCGS guide figures put the 1926-S at $11,500 in MS63 (PCGS Price Guide).
- 1936-D 3-1/2 Legs Buffalo Nickel — an over-polished die variety missing part of the bison’s front leg; see also the famous 1937-D three-legged variety, struck from a similarly over-polished die (Liberty Coin Service checklist).
- 1916 doubled die — a sharply doubled date variety that ranks with the overdate as a series trophy (Stack’s Bowers).
What drives the premium
- Varieties: the 1916 doubled die, 1918/7-D overdate, and 1937-D three-legged can each exceed the cost of a complete regular-issue set (Dr. Sol Taylor).
- Date visibility: because the date wears off first, Buffalo nickels with full, sharp dates bring premiums over “dateless” or partial-date examples (Stack’s Bowers).
- Strike: the hard copper-nickel alloy struck up weakly, especially at branch mints in the late 1910s and 1920s — sharp, fully detailed examples are worth more (Stack’s Bowers).
- Grade: most regular issues are affordable in circulated grades, but Mint State examples of the scarcer dates (1913 issues, teens mintmarks, 1921-S, 1926-S, 1931-S) climb steeply (Dr. Sol Taylor; PCGS Price Guide).
Specifications
- Composition: 75% copper, 25% nickel (Stack’s Bowers; PCGS)
- Weight: 5.00 g (Stack’s Bowers; PCGS)
- Diameter: 21.2 mm (Stack’s Bowers; PCGS)
- Edge: plain (Stack’s Bowers; PCGS)
- Designer: James Earle Fraser (Stack’s Bowers; PCGS)
- Years: 1913–1938 (no 1922) (Stack’s Bowers; Liberty Coin Service checklist)
- Mint marks: none (Philadelphia), D (Denver), S (San Francisco) — below FIVE CENTS on the reverse (BuffaloNickel.org)
Collector notes
- Type 1 and Type 2 are both needed for a complete type set — the raised-mound 1913 is a one-year design (Stack’s Bowers).
- Proofs exist for 1913 (both types), 1914–1916, and 1936–1937 — a separate specialty from the circulation issues (Liberty Coin Service checklist).
- Branch-mint coins of the 1920s are often softly struck; don’t confuse weak strike with wear when grading.
- The 1938-D is the final issue and the only 1938 Buffalo nickel — an affordable bookend for the set (PCGS Price Guide).
- Denver and San Francisco struck Buffalo nickels in most years of the series; Philadelphia issues carry no mint mark, as was standard for the era (BuffaloNickel.org).
Market check
Compare live listings for Buffalo nickel key dates on eBay:
Search eBay for Buffalo nickel key dates
As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.
FREE DOWNLOAD
Before you spend that coin, check it.
The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.
