Skip to main content

2005-P Minnesota ‘Extra Tree’ Quarter

Some 2005-P Minnesota quarters show a ghostly extra spruce tree hiding in the treeline — a doubled die reverse that turned a 25-cent coin into a $100+ collectible at its peak. With dozens of varieties documented, attribution is everything. Here’s how to find the valuable one.

What it is

The “Extra Tree” is a doubled die reverse (DDR) on the 2005-P Minnesota state quarter. A partial, ghostlike duplicate of a spruce tree appears just to the right of the existing tree line on the reverse. At least 78 different reverse doubled-die varieties have been documented for the Philadelphia issue alone (plus varieties from Denver and San Francisco), ranging from a microscopic tree-like lump to a full extra tree. PCGS designated the strongest and most desirable as FS-801, “Doubled Tree” DDR-001: a full extra spruce with complete boughs sitting just right of the fourth tree from the state outline, virtually in the center of the reverse. FS-801 is the only Minnesota extra-tree variety that commands serious money.

How it happens at the Mint

The error originated in the Mint’s single-squeeze hubbing process. The hub contacted a slightly tilted die blank and then snapped into alignment under striking pressure, and that rotational smear duplicated the spruce-tree design on the working die. Every coin struck from an affected die carries the same doubled tree. Because the misalignment varied from die to die, dozens of distinct doublings resulted — from faint shadowing to the dramatic full extra tree of FS-801.

Diagnostics: how to identify it

Flip the coin to the reverse and put it under a good light with a loupe. Find the state outline of Minnesota, then count the spruce trees to its right — there are four, with the rightmost being the smallest. Immediately to the right of that fourth tree, look for three ghostlike spruce boughs: a partial, raised duplicate tree floating in the field. On FS-801 these boughs are distinct and visible under 5x magnification. Minor varieties show only faint shadowing or a small nub in the same area.

Check the character of the doubling: genuine doubled-die doubling is rounded, raised, and three-dimensional. Machine doubling looks flat and shelf-like. Confirm the P mint mark and the standard 5.67-gram weight. The fastest confirmation is a side-by-side comparison with a normal 2005-P Minnesota quarter — once you know where to look, the extra tree jumps out.

Real error vs. post-mint damage

Most “extra tree” claims fail on two points. First, machine doubling — flat, shelf-like doubling from die bounce during striking — is common on these quarters and carries no premium; only rounded, raised hub doubling counts. Second, the faintest varieties are so subtle they can’t be seen with the unaided eye; these sell for a dollar or two and are not worth grading. Only the stronger doublings, led by FS-801, have real collector value.

Notable examples

When the variety surfaced in 2005, just weeks after the quarter’s April release, early specimens sold for $500 or more. As more examples were found, the market settled. The PCGS price guide lists FS-801 around $74 in MS60 and about $90 in MS65; strong certified examples typically trade in the $40–$200 range, with the finest known bringing around $275. At auction, exceptional pieces have reached approximately $800 — certified MS67 examples of the major variety. Minor varieties (FS-802 onward) sell for $5–$50.

Value drivers

Attribution matters enormously: a confirmed FS-801 and an unattributed minor variety can differ by $200 or more, so certification by PCGS or NGC pays for itself on strong examples. Strength of doubling is second — full, distinct boughs beat faint shadows. Grade is third, with uncirculated Red examples commanding the premiums. Buyers should beware of uncertified coins described loosely as “extra tree,” since most are minor varieties worth a few dollars.

Market check

Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:

Search eBay for 2005-P Minnesota ‘Extra Tree’ Quarter

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

Specifications and sources

Philadelphia Mint, 2005. Part of the 50 State Quarters program. Composition: copper-nickel clad (75% copper / 25% nickel outer layers, pure copper core). Weight: 5.67 grams. Diameter: 24.3 mm. Edge: reeded. Philadelphia mintage: 239,600,000. Major variety: FS-801 Doubled Tree DDR-001 (PCGS #144227), listed in the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties of United States Coins.

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.