Skip to main content

2004-S Proof Roosevelt Dime (25% Indented Strike): The Sealed-Set Discovery

Coin photo needed — no freely licensed image found. We publish only real photographs; this page will gain its photo when a usable one is located.

A 2004-S proof Roosevelt dime with a dramatic 25% obverse indent — found still sealed inside its original 2004 U.S. Mint proof set, where it had sat for 22 years. The only reported major striking error in a sealed U.S. proof set.

History
  • An unnamed dealer purchased the sealed 2004 proof set at the 2026 ANA World’s Fair of Money in Pittsburgh (August 25–29, 2026), recognized the dime needed expert attention, and contacted error specialist Mike Byers — publisher of MINTERRORNEWS Magazine — who subsequently acquired the set. (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • CoinWeek reported the discovery as “Major 2004-S Proof Dime Error Found Sealed in U.S. Proof Set” in late September 2026, with coverage in MINTERRORNEWS Magazine Issue 97.
  • The indent covers roughly one-quarter of the obverse. An indented strike happens when two planchets enter the coining chamber together and overlap: one planchet blocks part of the die from reaching the other, and the overlapping planchet forces a rounded depression into the affected coin. (CONECA and NGC definitions, via CoinWeek)
  • Byers — with 50 years specializing in mint errors — says he has never seen another major proof striking error sealed in an annual U.S. Mint proof set, checking auction records and consulting other specialists with no match. CoinWeek’s formulation: “the only reported major striking error known in a sealed United States Mint Proof Set,” with the caveat that the status could change if another surfaces. (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • Marks visible in the discovery photographs are on the clear plastic lens, not on the coins inside, per Byers. (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • Set context: the 2004 proof set was released June 3, 2004 at $22.95 — 11 coins with $2.96 face value, notable for the Westward Journey Nickel Series (the Peace Medal and Keelboat nickels, the first new nickel reverses since 1938, honoring the Louisiana Purchase and Lewis & Clark bicentennials). (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
Specifications
  • Denomination: 10 cents (one dime)
  • Composition: copper-nickel clad — 75% copper / 25% nickel outer layers bonded to a pure copper core (91.67% copper, 8.33% nickel overall)
  • Weight: 2.268 g; Diameter: 17.91 mm; Thickness: 1.35 mm
  • Edge: reeded, 118 reeds
  • Designer: John R. Sinnock; Mint: San Francisco (“S”); Strike: proof
  • Mintage: 1,789,488 clad proofs (PCGS CoinFacts, via CoinWeek). Note: the often-repeated 1,175,934 figure is the 2004-S silver proof dime (NGC) — a different coin.
Collector notes
  • No grade exists: a grading service never placed it in a holder, and no third-party error attribution has been reported — it remains uncertified in the sealed lens. Do not cite a grade for this coin. (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • No value has been published: the reporting gives no price estimate or auction result, so none is stated here.
  • Why it matters: modern proof errors are scarce because the Mint applies unusually high quality control to proof production — San Francisco proof coins in 2004 were struck at least twice on specially prepared, highly polished dies — and dramatically misshapen pieces face another chance of detection at packaging. This dime survived the strike, inspection, and packaging to be sealed into the lens: a documented breakdown of several stages of proof QC. (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • The sealed holder preserves the error in its original Mint context, which Byers argues “may ultimately prove more important to collectors than the dime’s numerical grade.” (CoinWeek, late September 2026)
  • No freely licensed photograph of this exact coin exists — the discovery images are CoinWeek/MINTERRORNEWS copyrighted. This page will gain its photo if a usable one is ever released. (research 2026-10-03)
Market check

Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:

Search eBay for 2004-S Proof Roosevelt Dime Errors

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.