Skip to main content
Obverse of the 1920 Maine Centennial half dollar: the arms of Maine with pine tree, moose, farmer and seaman, dated 1920.

1920 Maine Centennial Half Dollar: What’s It Worth?

1920 Maine Centennial Half Dollar: What’s It Worth?
Specifications
Denomination
Half dollar
Weight
12.5 g
Diameter
30.61 mm
Edge
Reeded
Obverse of the 1920 Maine Centennial half dollar: the arms of Maine with pine tree, moose, farmer and seaman, dated 1920.
The Maine Centennial half dollar obverse. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons.

Anthony de Francisci’s coin a year before the Peace dollar — Maine’s statehood centennial arrived too late for the party, spent years in a treasurer’s office, and then drifted into circulation, so clean original examples are the ones the market chases (Wikipedia; GreatCollections).

History
  • The Maine Centennial half dollar was struck in 1920 to honor the centennial of Maine’s admission to the Union on March 15, 1820. Governor Carl Milliken and Maine’s council wanted the coin partly as an advertisement for the planned centennial celebrations (Wikipedia).
  • H.R. 12460 was introduced by Maine’s Congressman John A. Peters on February 11, 1920, modeled on the 1918 Illinois Centennial act; it passed both houses without opposition and was signed by President Woodrow Wilson on May 10, 1920, authorizing up to 100,000 half dollars (Wikipedia).
  • The design fight is one of the great Mint-versus-state standoffs of the era: artist Harry Cochrane of Monmouth, Maine, prepared the sketches, and the Commission of Fine Arts’ sculptor-member James Earle Fraser called them “ordinary,” with chairman Charles Moore urging changes and warning the sketch “would bring humiliation to the people of Maine.” Maine officials refused, and Fraser’s own onetime student Anthony de Francisci was engaged to convert the sketches into plaster models; the Commission approved them on July 9, 1920 — a year before de Francisci designed the Peace dollar (Wikipedia).
  • The Philadelphia Mint struck 50,028 pieces in the late summer of 1920, including 28 for the 1921 Assay Commission, with no special care — they were ejected into bins, so many display bag marks. The coins arrived too late for the July 4 centennial celebrations in Portland, and the state treasurer at Augusta sold them off at $1 each; 30,000 sold immediately and the rest moved slowly over years, with sales not completing until at least 1929. Many pieces were spent in the years after 1920 and entered circulation (Wikipedia). This entry is part of the Classic U.S. Commemoratives series.
What is it worth
  • The 2015 deluxe edition of R. S. Yeoman’s A Guide Book of United States Coins lists the Maine half dollar from $140 to $685 depending on condition, and an exceptional piece sold for $7,050 in 2014 (Wikipedia).
  • Because the coins were bought singly by Maine residents and put away rather than collected at issue, survivors span a wider spread of grades than the collector-only commemoratives of the 1930s, which come almost exclusively uncirculated (GreatCollections).
  • On this issue, clean surfaces beat sharp strike: the heraldic design is shallow with broad fields, so every mark registers. Coins with the soft gray-gold patina of a century of undisturbed storage are what commemorative collectors chase; dipped or over-bright examples are markedly less wanted (GreatCollections).
What drives the premium
  • Originality: the market pays for undisturbed skin and original color over dipped white, which is abundant on this issue (GreatCollections).
  • Low high-grade survival: few went to collectors, and most surviving specimens show careless handling — Wikipedia notes the coin lists “for hundreds to thousands of dollars, depending on condition” (Wikipedia).
  • Type-set and run demand: it is a standard component of the commemorative half dollar type set and of any run of the early issues from 1918 to 1925 (GreatCollections).
  • De Francisci association: Peace dollar collectors know the sculptor’s name, even though Arlie Slabaugh noted the half dollar “does not resemble” his 1921 masterpiece (Wikipedia).
Specifications
  • Composition: 90.0% silver, 10.0% copper (Wikipedia)
  • Weight: 12.5 g (Wikipedia)
  • Silver content: 0.36169 troy oz (Wikipedia)
  • Diameter: 30.61 mm (Wikipedia)
  • Thickness: 2.15 mm (Wikipedia)
  • Edge: Reeded (Wikipedia)
  • Alignment: Not verified in consulted references
  • Designers: Obverse: arms of Maine — Anthony de Francisci, based on sketches by Harry Cochrane; reverse: pine wreath — Anthony de Francisci, based on sketches by Harry Cochrane (Wikipedia)
  • Mint: Philadelphia (no mintmark), 1920 (Wikipedia)
Collector notes
  • Mintage context: 50,028 struck in 1920, including 28 pieces for the Assay Commission — half the 100,000 authorized. Numismatic writer Q. David Bowers speculated that had the full authorized mintage been struck, most of the extra coins would have been returned and melted for lack of buyers (Wikipedia).
  • The obverse shows the arms of Maine at its center: a shield with an incuse pine tree, a reclining moose below, flanked by a farmer with a scythe (Agriculture) and a seaman with an anchor (Commerce), with the legend DIRIGO (“I direct”) and a five-pointed star above. The reverse is a wreath of pine needles and cones around MAINE CENTENNIAL 1820–1920 (Wikipedia).
  • Either Chief Engraver George T. Morgan or his assistant John R. Sinnock changed the moose and pine tree from relief (as de Francisci modeled them) to incuse, apparently to improve striking quality — with limited success, as full detail is missing on many coins (Wikipedia).
  • Art historian Cornelius Vermeule deprecated the piece — “it looks just like a prize medal for a county fair” — though he blamed the required specifications rather than de Francisci (Wikipedia).
Market check

Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:

Search eBay for 1920 Maine Centennial Half Dollar

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

Sources

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.