Skip to main content

1867-S Liberty Head Half Eagle: The $97,600 Cigar-Box Coin

Specifications
Denomination
Half eagle ($5)
Series
Liberty Head Half Eagle — With Motto (1866–1908)
Designer
Christian Gobrecht
Engraver
Christian Gobrecht
Years of issue
1867
Composition
90% Gold, 10% Copper
Weight
8.359 g
Diameter
21.6 mm
Edge
Reeded
Key mintages
29,000 struck at San Francisco (PCGS). PCGS survival estimate ~75 in all grades; population 1 in MS63 (finest known), one other Mint State example (MS61). Auction record $97,600, Heritage GACC Signature #1397, October 2026.
Melt value: $854.78gold $3,533.94/ozt, copper $0.37/ozt · prices as of Nov 22, 2026
1866 Liberty Head half eagle (with motto), obverse and reverse — a type coin of the same design as the 1867-S, shown because no freely licensed photo of the 1867-S exists; this is not the cigar-box coin
National Numismatic Collection, National Museum of American History (Smithsonian Institution), via Wikimedia Commons — public domain. Photo shows an 1866 type coin, not the auctioned 1867-S.

San Francisco struck just 29,000 Liberty Head half eagles in 1867 and PCGS estimates only about 75 survive — in 2026 a previously unknown example surfaced in a Texas cigar box, graded PCGS MS63, and sold for $97,600, more than four times the date’s previous auction record.

History
  • The Liberty Head half eagle, designed by Christian Gobrecht, was struck from 1839 to 1908 and is the only U.S. coin type produced at all seven federal mints of its era (Stack’s Bowers, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • Following the Coinage Act of March 1865, the motto IN GOD WE TRUST was added on a ribbon above the eagle in 1866, creating the “With Motto” type struck through 1908; the 1867-S belongs to this type (Stack’s Bowers; Greysheet, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • The San Francisco Mint struck 29,000 half eagles in 1867 (PCGS, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • Survival was brutal despite the five-figure mintage: PCGS estimates only about 75 examples survive across all grades, and specialists put the total at fewer than 100 (PCGS; CoinWeek, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • In 2026, estate liquidator Michael Precht found a green milk crate in the corner of a bedroom closet during an estate evaluation in Buda, Texas; inside a cigar box of 19th-century coins sat an 1867-S half eagle. The coins had come from family members in Columbus, Ohio and, by family account, from the heirs’ great-grandfather, a Union soldier discharged in 1865; the group had been passed down two generations without anyone recognizing the coin (PCGS; CoinWeek, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • PCGS graded the discovery coin MS63 — the finest known 1867-S, two full grade points above the next-finest example (MS61), a population of one at that grade, and the first 1867-S ever to reach MS63 (PCGS, accessed 2026-10-13).
  • Offered at Heritage Auctions’ GACC U.S. Coins Signature Auction #1397 (October 8–9, 2026), the coin sold for $97,600 — more than four times the previous auction record of $22,800, a figure Heritage had matched twice, most recently in 2021 (CoinWeek, accessed 2026-10-13).
Key dates and varieties
  • 1867-S: 29,000 struck at San Francisco; PCGS survival estimate ~75 in all grades (PCGS)
  • 1867-S finest known: PCGS MS63, population 1, discovered in a Buda, Texas estate in 2026; next finest MS61 (PCGS)
  • 1867-S auction record: $97,600 (Heritage GACC #1397, October 2026); previous record $22,800, set twice, most recently 2021 (CoinWeek)
  • Type context: Liberty Head half eagle 1839–1908; the With Motto subtype begins in 1866 (Stack’s Bowers)
Specifications
  • Denomination: Half eagle ($5 gold)
  • Composition: 90% gold, 10% copper (PCGS CoinFacts)
  • Weight: 8.359 g (Greysheet)
  • Diameter: 21.6 mm (Stack’s Bowers)
  • Edge: Reeded (PCGS CoinFacts)
  • Gold content: 0.2418 troy oz (JM Bullion)
  • Mint mark: S (San Francisco)
  • Mint: San Francisco
  • Designer: Christian Gobrecht (PCGS CoinFacts)
  • Finish: Circulation strike
  • Mintage (1867-S): 29,000 (PCGS)
Collector notes
  • The 1867-S is a condition rarity, not just a date rarity: only two Mint State examples are reported — the MS63 discovery coin and a single MS61 (PCGS; CoinWeek).
  • The photo on this page is a public-domain 1866 With Motto type coin from the Smithsonian’s National Numismatic Collection — it is NOT the cigar-box 1867-S, whose images are copyrighted Heritage/PCGS auction photographs.
  • The $97,600 record belongs to the unique finest-known coin; it does not reprice ordinary circulated 1867-S examples, which trade on the date’s scarcity, not the record.
  • Most With Motto half eagles are common dates that trade close to their gold value — the 1867-S premium is date-specific, so attribution and certification matter. Buy certified examples.
  • Beware altered mint marks on better-date Liberty Head gold: an added “S” can turn a common Philadelphia coin into a fake rarity. Third-party certification is the standard check.
Market check

Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:

Search eBay for 1867-S Liberty Head Half Eagle

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

Live on eBay

Live asking prices — not sale records.

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.