Skip to main content

1971 No-S Jefferson Nickel

A 1971 proof nickel that left San Francisco without its “S” mintmark — the only Jefferson nickel ever struck without its intended mintmark. It hides in ordinary-looking proof sets, and the best ones have sold for over $8,000.

What it is

The 1971 “No S” Jefferson nickel is a proof error: a proof die intended for the San Francisco Mint was put into service without the S mintmark ever being punched into it. The resulting coins look like ordinary 1971 proof nickels — except the S that should appear on the reverse is simply missing. It is the only coin in the entire Jefferson nickel series struck without its intended mintmark (PCGS CoinFacts, Jaime Hernandez).

The error is cataloged as FS-501 in the Fivaz-Stanton Cherrypickers’ Guide (CoinWeek). The coins were released inside 1971 proof sets, where collectors have been pulling them ever since.

How it happens at the Mint

In this era, proof dies were prepared at Philadelphia and the mintmark was hand-punched into each working die by the engraving department before the die was shipped to San Francisco for proof production. On at least one nickel proof die, that step was skipped: the engraving department forgot to apply the S mintmark, and the unmarked die went on to strike proof planchets (CoinWeek).

Diagnostics: how to identify it

Two things must be true. First, the coin must be a proof — mirrorlike fields, needle-sharp details, often with frosted (cameo) devices. Second, it must lack the S mintmark on the obverse, just below the date — that is where the S sits on a normal 1971-S proof nickel (CoinWeek; Greysheet). This matters because ordinary 1971 circulation nickels from Philadelphia also carry no mintmark — so a shiny-looking coin without an S is not automatically the error; the proof finish is what qualifies it. The first reported example surfaced in a 1971 proof set on December 29, 1971, and the Mint confirmed its authenticity (CoinWeek).

Genuine examples show no trace of the mintmark — no ghost outline, no tool marks. Cameo and deep-cameo contrast are the big value multipliers, and certification by PCGS or NGC is effectively required for a serious sale, since the attribution is the entire value.

Real error vs. post-mint damage

An S mintmark cannot be legitimately “missing” from wear: it would take deliberate removal, which leaves disturbances in the surrounding field, scratches, or an unnatural flat spot. A genuine No-S shows pristine original proof surfaces where the mintmark should be. If there is any sign of smoothing or tooling near the mintmark area, treat the coin as altered, not as the error.

Notable examples

The U.S. Mint reported that 1,655 examples of the 1971 No S proof nickel were struck — an unusually precise figure for a mintmark error — though survival estimates and grading-service populations suggest far fewer remain today, with many likely still undiscovered in original proof sets (CoinWeek). PCGS estimates that possibly several hundred examples exist in plain proof, a couple hundred with cameo surfaces, and no more than about 50 with deep-cameo surfaces (PCGS CoinFacts, Jaime Hernandez).

Record prices climb with cameo contrast: PCGS lists auction records of $4,050 for a PR69 (eBay, December 2021), $4,313 for a PR69CAM (Heritage, June 2005), and $8,100 for a PR69DCAM (Heritage, May 2023). A PR69DCAM brought $4,320 at Stack’s Bowers in March 2026, and an NGC-graded PR69 brought a then-record $2,070 at the Heritage FUN auction in January 2012 (Greysheet; CoinWeek). Typical graded examples in PR67–PR68 trade in the roughly $700–$1,500 range depending on cameo designation (CoinWeek; Greysheet).

Value drivers

Cameo designation is the dominant driver: deep-cameo examples are an order of magnitude rarer and priced accordingly. Grade matters next, then eye appeal and originality of the proof surfaces. Because the error is only visible under close inspection, original untouched proof sets remain a plausible hunting ground — every 1971 proof set ever sold is a potential hiding place.

Market check

Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:

Search eBay for 1971 No-S Jefferson Nickel

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

Specifications and sources

Designer: Felix Schlag. Weight: 5.00 grams. Diameter: 21.20 mm. Composition: 75% copper, 25% nickel. Edge: plain. Strike: proof (San Francisco). Overall 1971 proof mintage: 3,220,733 pieces — the No-S error is a small, unrecorded fraction of that total (PCGS CoinFacts).

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.