
Specifications
- Denomination
- Half dollar
- Designer
- Gertrude K. Lathrop
- Weight
- 12.5 g
- Diameter
- 30.61 mm
- Edge
- Reeded

Dated 1938 but struck in 1937, the New Rochelle 250th Anniversary half dollar — the last new-design commemorative struck by the Mint until 1946 — has a net mintage of just 15,266 coins, and the 2018 deluxe Red Book lists it at $310 to $425 depending on condition (Wikipedia).
History
- New Rochelle, New York, was founded by Huguenots from La Rochelle, France, in 1688; their agent Jacob Leisler bought some 6,000 acres from John Pell on condition that he present Pell’s heirs with “one fatt calfe” every June 24 if demanded. The 250th anniversary of the settlement fell in 1938 (Wikipedia).
- Members of the Westchester County Coin Club — including Pitt M. Skipton and dealer Julius Guttag — pushed the issue to fund the anniversary celebrations without drawing on Depression-strained taxpayers. Bills were introduced in January 1936, and after the anti-abuse amendments of Senator Alva B. Adams (single mint, a single date, large minimum tranches), President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the bill into law on May 5, 1936 (Wikipedia).
- The committee first hired Lorrilard Wise, but the Commission of Fine Arts rejected his designs and asked for a new sculptor. Gertrude K. Lathrop — hired on the strength of her 1936 Albany Charter half dollar — chose the “fatt calfe” for the obverse and the fleur-de-lis (an element of the city seal, nodding to La Rochelle) for the reverse; the CFA approved both on February 18, 1937. The Philadelphia Mint struck the coins in 1937, dated 1938 as the law required (Wikipedia; ANA).
- Sold for $2 each locally and by mail order to all 48 states and internationally through the First National Bank of New Rochelle, sales slowed and 9,749 pieces were returned to the Mint for redemption and melting, leaving a net mintage of 15,266 including assay pieces. This entry is part of the Classic U.S. Commemoratives series (Wikipedia).
What is it worth
- The 2018 deluxe (Mega Red, 4th edition) A Guide Book of United States Coins lists the piece for between $310 and $425 depending on condition (Wikipedia).
- The issue appreciated steadily: $1.75 by 1940, $6 by 1950, $67 by 1970, and $500 by 1985 (Wikipedia).
- At the top end, an exceptional specimen sold for $3,593 in 2006 (Wikipedia).
What drives the premium
- Low net mintage: the 9,749 melted coins cut the original 25,015 strikings to 15,266 — among the lowest net mintages of the 1936–38 commemorative flood (Wikipedia; Numismatic News).
- End-of-era status: it was the last new-design commemorative struck by the Mint until 1946, giving it a natural “bookend” appeal in a 144-piece set (Wikipedia).
- Proofs: fifty pieces were struck in proof on polished planchets, boxed with a silver medal and presented to dignitaries and club members, plus at least one matte proof for Mint Chief Engraver John R. Sinnock (Wikipedia).
- Design charm: Lathrop intended “a touch of humor while maintaining dignity and beauty” — the real Guernsey calf she modeled, borrowed from a congressman’s farm, grew so used to her that it would kiss her on the nose (Wikipedia).
Specifications
- Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper (Wikipedia)
- Weight: 12.5 g (Wikipedia)
- Silver content: 0.36169 troy oz (Wikipedia)
- Diameter: 30.61 mm (Wikipedia)
- Thickness: 2.15 mm (Wikipedia)
- Edge: Reeded (Wikipedia)
- Alignment: Not verified in consulted references
- Designer: Gertrude K. Lathrop (Wikipedia)
- Mint: Philadelphia (no mintmark); dated 1938, struck 1937 (Wikipedia)
Collector notes
- Mintage context: 25,015 struck including 15 for the Assay Commission; 9,749 melted mid-1938; net 15,266 (Wikipedia).
- Obverse details: John Pell in period dress holding the roped fatted calf; “SETTLED 1688 INCORPORATED 1899” above and “NEW ROCHELLE NEW YORK” below; Lathrop’s GL initials in the lower right field. The reverse centers the fleur-de-lis with the 1938 date just above the denomination (ANA; Wikipedia).
- The ANA notes it is the last United States coin to have denticles along the rim (ANA).
- Club members bought several hundred pieces at face value when sales stalled — so coins with old-holder or club provenance do surface (Numismatic News).
Market check
Compare live listings for this coin on eBay:
Search eBay for 1938 New Rochelle Half Dollar
As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.
Sources
FREE DOWNLOAD
Before you spend that coin, check it.
The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation β including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.
