Skip to main content

1964-D Peace Dollar: The Rarest Modern U.S. Coin?



The 1964-D Peace dollar was struck by the Denver Mint in 1965, never released, and reportedly melted — no genuine example is known to exist. Here’s the documented history, and why you should never pay for one.

History
  • In the mid-1960s, a coin shortage led Congress to authorize new silver dollars; the Denver Mint struck 316,076 Peace dollars dated 1964 in May 1965 — months after their date — and none ever left the Mint (ANA; CoinWeek).
  • The silver-dollar authorization came amid a nationwide coin shortage in the mid-1960s; silver was eliminated from dimes and quarters the same year the dollars were struck (Numismatic News; Wikipedia).
  • The plan was abandoned before release: rising silver prices made a 90% silver dollar unworkable, and the Mint reported that every struck piece was melted (Numismatic News).
  • No 1964-D Peace dollar has ever been legally owned, publicly exhibited, or certified — and Peace dollar historian Roger Burdette has said he has never seen a coin or even a photograph, and that whether any survivor exists is unknown (Collectors Weekly).
What is it worth?
  • There is no legitimate market price: with no genuine example legally collectible, any “price” quoted for a 1964-D Peace dollar is speculation (CoinWeek).
  • Because no legal specimen exists, the 1964-D has no price-guide value — only a story (CoinWeek).
  • The Mint’s position is that all 316,076 pieces were destroyed; the coins were never issued (Numismatic News).
What drives the premium
  • Absolute rarity: a confirmed genuine example would be unique or nearly so — the ultimate 20th-century U.S. rarity (CoinWeek).
  • Legal status: no 1964-D Peace dollar is known in private hands or has been certified by a major grading service (Collectors Weekly; CoinWeek).
  • The story: the “dollar that never was” narrative — authorized, struck, then erased — is what sustains collector fascination (CoinWeek).
How to identify fakes
  • Fantasy pieces and private overstrikes marked 1964-D exist and are sold as novelties — they are not U.S. Mint products and carry no numismatic premium as genuine coins (PeaceDollars.com).
  • Any offered “1964-D Peace dollar” should be treated as a fantasy or counterfeit unless and until a major grading service and the U.S. government say otherwise — neither has happened (CoinWeek).
  • Compare against a genuine 1921–1935 Peace dollar: the 1964-D used the same de Francisci design, so its diagnostics match the classic series (Numismedia).
  • Never pay genuine-coin money for a 1964-D Peace dollar: there is no authentication path that makes such a purchase legitimate today (CoinWeek).
  • Basic tests still apply: a genuine Peace dollar weighs 26.73 g and measures 38.1 mm — base-metal or wrong-sized fantasy pieces fail immediately (JM Bullion).
Specifications (as struck, 1965)
  • Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper — the standard Peace dollar alloy (JM Bullion)
  • Weight: 26.73 g — standard Peace dollar specification (JM Bullion)
  • Diameter: 38.1 mm — standard Peace dollar specification (JM Bullion)
  • Designer: Anthony de Francisci (Numismedia)
  • Reported mintage: 316,076 — manufactured at Denver in May 1965, dated 1964, never issued, reported melted (ANA; CoinWeek; Numismatic News)
Collector notes
  • For the classic 1921–1935 series, see our Peace Dollar Series Guide — every coin there is real, legal, and collectible.
  • The 1964-D is excluded from Peace dollar sets by definition: the collectible series runs 1921–1935 (Numismedia).
  • The 1964-D story is a reminder to buy the coin, not the story: documentation and legal title matter as much as rarity.
  • Modern private “1964-D” restrikes are collectibles only as novelties — price them as such (PeaceDollars.com).
Market check

Recent eBay sales

The wiki started tracking eBay sales for this coin on September 26, 2026. Confirmed sales will appear here as our monitor observes them — check back in a few days.

Research 1964-D Peace dollar history and fantasy pieces on eBay:

Search eBay for 1964-D Peace dollar items

As an eBay Partner, The Coin Wiki may earn from qualifying purchases.

FREE DOWNLOAD

Before you spend that coin, check it.

The Pocket Change Key-Date Checklist covers the cents, nickels, dimes, quarters and halves still hiding in circulation — including the 1943 and 1983 errors worth five figures. One page to print, a lifetime of jars to check.

One email with your checklist, then occasional key-date finds and new entries. Unsubscribe anytime.